How To Critique (Other Writers' Work)

How To Critique (Other Writers’ Work)

Here’s an extract from an excellent article by Melissa Donovan on the Writing Forward blog, on how to critique other writers’ work.  Please pay particular attention to the tip on being compassionate!  Read the full article here.

“Constructive criticism involves a little compassion. If someone cares enough about their work to show it around and invite feedback, then it’s probably something in which they are emotionally invested. If you are the person they feel is qualified to provide that feedback, then embrace the invitation as an honor, and approach it with respect.

It can be awkward at first — after all, who wants to be the bearer of bad news (and almost every critique contains at least a little bad news)? After you do a few critiques, you’ll get the hang of it, and it will become easier and more natural. Just keep these basic tips on how to critique in mind:

  • Don’t provide a critique unless you’ve been invited to do so.
  • Don’t waste time on writers who are looking for praise. Seek out writers who want feedback that will genuinely help them improve their work.
  • Take time and make an effort so you can offer a critique that is thoughtful and helpful; otherwise, just politely decline.
  • Critique the writing, not the writer.
  • Always start with the strengths, then address the weaknesses and problem areas using positive language.
  • Be objective, especially if the piece you’re critiquing is not in a style or genre that you prefer.
  • Make solid suggestions for improvement. Don’t be vague.
  • Follow up with the writer to offer support and encouragement.”
Related Posts
No related posts for this content

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

efficacy - 31 December 2018

Hi Nicola,

I just signed up for your “writing club world” and what I miss most in the almost-anonymous review process is illustrated by the final point on the list in this blog post “Follow up with the writer to offer support and encouragement.”

Am I missing something? Is a review always just a review and never part of an ongoing conversation?

    Nicola Cairncross - 3 January 2019

    Dear Frances, we are constantly improving on the back end, responding to requests and are just creating a Writers Directory that will enable registered writers to contact each other via social media, and visit websites etc. Not everyone will add their details but if they do, further contact will be possible. Thanks for your support and suggestions. Nicola

Leave a Reply: